"ARTS SMART"
Patricia Ryan
Faculty of Education
Winter 1994
Providing a decent place for arts in our schools may
be one of the most important first steps we can take to bring about genuine
school reform. (Eisner 1992)
The purpose of this paper is to address how a new emphasis
on the arts in curriculum is necessary if our schools are to produce adults
of the twenty-first century who are perceptive, flexible, creative, adaptable
and, most of all, able to solve problems and make decisions in a multiplicity
of personal and professional situations as yet unimagined. It is
essential that our schools provide experiences that stimulate the imagination
and pose problems that require creative solutions. The unique properties
of art (not always inherent in other academic subjects) enhance the development
of the creative and intuitive thinking process towards fully functioning
individuals who will cope with the challenges of our evolving culture.
The notion of culture includes several aspects of people's lives
of which one aspect is technology. A technological phenomenon that
is currently becoming an extremely popular development is multimedia.
This industry has many implications for the arts and for the job market
that is open to creative individuals. Canada's multimedia industry
is rapidly emerging. More and more business corporations realize
that they must recruit artists to assist in the design and creation of
multimedia products and services. The arts are seen by computer communicators
as being the engine to promote other Canadian industries in the global
marketplace.
Multimedia is a type of presentation that involves the directed
control of several forms of communications such as text display, graphics,
still imagery, animation, sound and music. A multimedia presentation
is a composite of many audio-visual sources and allows the discriminating
viewer to proceed at a desired pace and with some level of interaction.
The user controls the order and speed of the presentation. With some
systems the user, or viewer, can import information from various sources,
merging them into a new assembly or package, thus creating a new presentation,
product or service. Multimedia can be sold as products or services,
and it is also used to produce these products or services.
Canadian companies having a successful background in corporate
communications understand the value of artists in the emerging market place.
President Matthew Diamond of Digital Presentations expresses the view of
many:
Our focus as a company is now on creativity and recruiting
artists who are acquainted with the new technology and possess the skills
to use it. Campbell (1993), p. 14.
Michael Keefe, director of multimedia, Multiple Images Inc.
comments,
As cultural - and other - multimedia products and services become
more and more refined, artists' skill and imagination provide what is often
a subtle but critical improvement in the presentation. This improvement
becomes the competitive edge in the information-glutted marketplace.
(Campbell, 1993: 14)
We are on the threshold of a new age - a high tech information
age where there is the greatest explosion of knowledge in the history of
mankind. Information is proliferating at a phenomenal rate and information
processing has become the backbone of a whole new era. Storing, retrieving,
creating, distributing and exchanging information, using tools of high
technology, are now important aspects of our economy and the foci of many
jobs which did not exist a decade ago.
The computer is an instrument central to the late twentieth century
methods of work and play. It is still in a state of technological
infancy. Yet, just as the steam engine spurred the industrial revolution,
so has the micro-chip launched us into the technological revolution.
The invention of interactive multimedia has allowed computers to become
a creative environment - a new medium - for discovering the human interweave
of ideas. This new media environment challenges our educational systems
to meet the needs of society. This will mean altering our goals to
reflect the changing needs.
Specific skills and knowledge areas must be developed, added to,
or emphasized in our school curriculum in order to prepare our students
to perform adequately in the high technology information age. With
a focus on developing skills for lifelong learning, information processing
skills, and with computer proficiency as the guiding light, our curriculum
planners may be successful in exposing today's students to the "new basics"
(Caissy, 1989).
Because of the rapid change in society and the workplace, education
and learning are no longer confined to the years spent in school.
Current high school graduates may have to change their jobs four or five
times. Updating job skills and retraining are quite common occurrences.
Students must be equipped with skills that allow them to fulfil current
job requirements and to adapt to new ones. Students must develop
a base of learning and thinking skills that will enable them to become
independent learners and will allow them to apply, transfer and use skills
in a variety of circumstances and settings. These ideas are not new
- but the development of these skills has been limited.
Toffler (1990), Naisbett (1990), Postman (1992), and others writing
about social change, see a growing need on the part of workers for more
creativity, problem solving skills, perceptual development and evaluation
skills. In our economy today innovative techniques for bringing new
products on line are necessary for our survival. Innovation demands
that ideas are free flowing, which in turn requires that workers need to
be creative and well educated. Worker ideas are eagerly sought by
many companies. The "innovation imperative", as Toffler (1990) called
it, requires a diversity of ideas for survival. In a society where
new fragmentations and new forms of synthesis occur often, both workers
and leaders need to develop the ability to cope by becoming more comfortable
with ambiguity and less fearful of the unknown. A person with the
ability to demonstrate art knowledge and art proficiency will have a better
chance of procuring employment in the workplace of the future.
At the Arts Work Conference, Toronto (1992), Professor
Ken Robinson addressed the topic The Neglect of Arts in Schools.
He argued for the range of complex and related roles that the arts fulfil
in the whole curriculum. These include:
(a) Developing the full variety of children's intelligence.
...The arts are fundamental ways of organizing our understanding
of the world and call on profound qualities of discipline and insight.
They must be included in education wherever schools are concerned to develop
the full range of children's intelligence and abilities.
(b) Developing the capacity for creative thought and action.
As the rate of change accelerates in all areas of social life,
two qualities in young people are becoming more important - those of capability
and adaptability ... Industry and commerce want those entering employment
to show powers of innovation, initiative and application in solving problems
and pursuing opportunities. These are widely held to be prerequisites
for economic health. For the growing numbers of those for whom conventional
employment is ceasing to be an option, these powers may be more important.
Creative thought and action should be fostered in all areas of education.
In the arts they are central.
(c) The exploration of values.
Feelings are intimately concerned with values. Many for
example are considered as vices or virtues - lust, envy, hope, despair,
etc. The education of feelings is thus concerned with moral issues
and the exploration of values. An education which sets out to help
young people make sense of - and contribute to - the world in which they
live must be concerned with helping them to investigate their own values
and those of others. Artists are characteristically concerned with
such things; with the evaluation and the re-evaluation of the world around
them.
(d) The education of feeling and sensibility.
No sensible person would doubt the value of intellectual activity
and development. The danger lies in the separation of this from other
capabilities. Mainstream Western philosophy since the seventeenth
century has held that feelings and emotions disrupt the pursuit of knowledge
through the intellect and should be disregarded in the classroom.
Some have argued against this that the free expression of emotion is essential
to healthy development, and this is the value of the arts in the schools.
Both views divide intellect from emotion, thus neglecting the intimate
relationships between them. The arts are not outpourings of emotion.
They are disciplined forms of inquiry and expression that help to organize
feelings and ideas about experience. The need for young people to
do this, rather than just to give vent to emotions or to have them ignored,
must be responded to in schools. The arts provide the natural means
for this.
(e) Understanding cultural change and differences.
The arts are characteristic expressions of any culture and evolve
as part of it. In a multicultural society, schools have important
responsibilities with regard to cultural education. The arts are
important here for two reasons. First, both the practical and the
discriminating enjoyment of the arts involve observation, analysis, and
evaluation of personal and social experience. Second, the products
of the arts - plays, paintings, literature, music, dancing, sculpture,
and so on - are integral parts of the social culture and are among those
things children need to experience in coming to understand it.
(f) Developing physical and perceptual skills.
Children need to be enabled not only to have ideas about the
world, but to act on it. Natural abilities must be developed of a
range of qualities and skills with a wide application and value.
Fairly recent, but now familiar, research on brain hemisphericity
(Sperry, 1975; Bogen 1975; Orstein 1973) substantiates the importance of
developing imagination and divergent thought processes. Research
into the psychology of the brain suggests that two hemispheres of the brain
are involved in different but related forms of perception and conception.
One summary of this thesis is given by Ornstein (1975) who suggests that:
The left hemisphere is largely involved in the analytical,
logical thinking, especially in verbal and mathematical functions.
Its mode or operation is primarily linear. This hemisphere tends
to process information sequentially. The right hemisphere is involved
in orientation in space and recognition of faces. It processes information
more diffusely and is more rationally simultaneous in its mode of operation.
These two sets of functions are complementary. The implication
is not that education should now become right-brained. It is that
equal emphasis should be placed on the capacities of both hemispheres and
the relationships between them. Carl Sagan (1979) makes this point
forcibly:
There is no way to tell whether the patterns extracted
by the right hemisphere are real or imagined without subjecting them to
left hemisphere scrutiny. On the other hand, mere critical thinking
without creative and intuitive insights and search for new patterns, is
sterile or doomed. To solve complex problems in changing circumstances
requires the activity of both cerebral hemispheres. The path to the
future lies through the corpus callosum.
Betty Edwards (1979), author of Drawing on the Right Side
of the Brain, has been conducting research using art to unlock right-brain
potential. Results of her studies imply that training in art might
be used as a means of teaching students to improve their perceptual skills
and to utilize more fully their right-hemisphere capabilities. Schools
must provide a climate in which both sides of the brain are cherished and
nourished. Some learning calls for logical, analytical thinking.
However, computers and data banks can hold more information than one mind
ever could, and it is here that the ability to think creatively and with
feeling will be crucial in the child's future.
In the Betrayal of Youth, James Hemmings (1980) observes
that education is dominated by the "academic illusion", the idea that:
The supreme role of education is the development of the
logical, intellectual, analytic aspects of the mind and that other aspects,
the social, perceptive, affective, practical, intuitive, aesthetic, imaginative
and creative aspects are of minor importance - worth a nod or two here
or there but to be valued as nothing beside the glories of academic excellence.
This is not an argument against academic education - it is
an argument against the confusion of academic ability in general.
Academic ability involves the capacity for logical - deductive reason and
for propositional knowledge. These are important abilities, but there
is more to a child's mind than these alone.
Eisner (1992: 594) states that the core contributions of
the arts and their potential role in furthering the aims of education as
follows:
1. Not all problems have single correct answers.
One of the important lessons that the arts teach is that solutions
to problems take many forms. This lesson from the arts world would
not be so important were not the fact that so much of what is taught in
school teaches just the opposite lesson. Almost all of the basic
skills taught in the primary grades teach children that there is only once
correct answer to any question and only one correct solution to any problem.
The arts teach a different lesson. They celebrate imagination, multiple
perspectives, and the importance of personal interpretation. The
last thing a modern teacher in art wants is a class full of standardized
performances on a given task. When the curriculum as a whole is so
heavily saturated with tasks and expectations that demand fealty to rule,
opportunities to think in a unique way are diminished. When carried
to an extreme the school's program becomes intellectually debilitating.
2. The form of a thing is part of its content.
We have a tendency in our schools to separate form from content.
Form is regarded as the shape something takes, and content is the meaning
something conveys. As Dewey pointed out, perception ceases when recognition
begins. Assigning a label to an entity is an act of categorization
and exploration of their uniqueness stops. The arts, however, teach
the child that the grass is not simply green: it is lavender, grey
and gold. And when it is green its varieties are endless. In
the arts and in very much of life, the form something takes is very much
part of its content. In fact what the content is often depends on
the form it takes. Eisner accepts the fact that some of the features
the arts possess are also found in the sciences. The products of
science have their own aesthetic features: the parsimony of theory,
the beauty of conceptual models, the elegance of experiments, and the imagination
and insight of interpretation. The point Eisner makes is that the
difference between the arts and the sciences is in the context of creation.
A work of science is a work of art.
3. Having fixed objectives and pursuing clear-cut methods for
achieving them are not always the most rational way of dealing with the
world. The arts teach that goals need to be flexible and that
surprise counts: that chance, as Aristotle wisely remarked, is something
that art loves; that being open to the unanticipated opportunities that
inevitably emerge in the context of action increases insight; and that
purposeful flexibility rather than rigid adherence to prior plans is more
likely to yield something of value.
In the context of much of today's schooling, the lessons taught
by the arts are closer to what successful and intelligent corporations
do and to what cognitive psychologists are discovering constitute the most
sophisticated forms of thinking. These recent psychological discoveries
are lessons artists have long understood. What are these lessons?
They are that solving complex problems require attention discrete to wholes,
not simply to parts: that most complex problems have no algorithms
solutions; that nuance counts; and that purposes and goals must remain
flexible in order to exploit opportunities that one cannot foresee.
The problems in life are much like the problems encountered in
the arts. They are problems that are often subtle, occasionally ambiguous,
and sometimes dilemma-like. One would think that schools that wanted
to prepare students for life would employ tasks and problems similar to
those found outside of schools. This is hardly the case. Life
outside of school is seldom like school assignments - and hardly ever -
like a multiple choice test.
4. In addition to their expressive function, the arts perform
another function of critical importance.
That contribution hinges on a distinction between expression
and discovery. In the arts, students learn that some kinds of meaning
may require the expressive forms that the arts make possible. The
arts provide the forms through which insight and feeling can emerge in
the public world.
But the arts also make discovery possible. Discovery occurs
as students learn through adventures in the arts something of the possibilities
of human experiences. The arts can help students find their individual
capacity to feel and imagine.
The arts more than most fields, put a premium on activities that
can help students discover the special qualities of experience we call
aesthetic.
Culture ought to include significant opportunities for students
to experience the arts and to learn to use them to create a life worth
living. Art is a part of the cultural heritage of every society.
The arts can make an impact on a scale that is literally worldwide.
Our culture regards the arts as among the highest of human achievements.
We build places we call museums to display the fruits of artistic inquiry
and construct concert halls to experience the heights we can reach through
music, drama and dance. Yet we provide little place for them in our
schools. Approximately 80% of all secondary students never enrol
in a fine arts course and we are being told by such writers as Allan Bloom
(1987) and E.D. Hirsch (1987) that students, even those in prestigious
universities, are culturally illiterate.
If one were to produce a report card for Newfoundland schools
the place of arts in the curriculum would reflect a low level of priority
in comparison to other areas of the curriculum. Our High Schools
are still expected to priorize within the norms of math and science above
all else. While art and drama are integral to every high school's
list of courses available, it is a fact of life that those classes are
filled with the low-academic non-achiever type. The question one
must ask is WHY? - why deny our top students exposure to the arts?
The answer lies with the increased emphasis placed on raising the level
of statistical performance in math and science of our Newfoundland students
in comparison to national norms. While no one wishes to down play
the relevant importance of math and science in today's changing society,
it is imperative that the benefits of exposure to the arts be given equal
recognition. This situation is compounded by the fact that curriculum
decision makers themselves are a product of a past environment with a very
limited exposure to the arts. The result of access denied is a program
of education that leaves most students unable to participate in the arts.
Artistic literacy is a rare educational commodity.
Like the young child in awe of the miracle of the emerging bean
plants, we look with wonder towards a rapidly unfolding future. Children
of today and teachers preparing for their profession will shortly advance
into the 21st century and the education they receive will need to prepare
them for unknown social changes and technological advances. Only
through a multifaceted education program that develops divergent thinking
- that encourages intuitive as well as rational thought processes - can
today's younger learner begin to be prepared to cope with the rapidly changing
aspects of a technologically oriented world. The information age
changes are dictating that art programs are essential. In educational
reform a richer nurturant culture can be created for our students if they
are given the opportunity to experience the arts.
Powerfully, Tennyson closes Ulysses' epic quest
for knowledge of the world in body, mind and spirit:
...to strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield -
Tennyson.
That same theme is relevant today as educators enable students
to understand more about themselves in the third millennium techno-culture.
REFERENCES
Bloom, Allan (1987). The Closing of the American Mind.
New York: Simon and Schuster.
Caissy, Gail A. (1989). "Curriculum For the Information
Age." Educational Horizon, (pp. 44, 45).
Campbell, Burke (1993). "Multimedia: An Awakening
Giant." Industry & Science Canada, (p. 14).
Daggett, William P. (1993). "An Educator's Definition
of Technological Literacy." New York State Education Department.
Eisner, Elliot (1992). "The Misunderstood Role of the Arts
in Human Development." Phi Delta Kappan (pp. 591-596).
Gardner, Howard (1988). "On Assessment in the Arts."
Educational Leadership, January (pp. 30-34).
Hemming, J. (1970). The Economic Importance of the Arts
in Britain. Policy Studies Institute, London.
Herberholz, B. & Hanson, L. (1990). Early Childhood
Art. W.C. Brown Pub., Dubusque, IA, (pp. xv-xxvii).
Hicks, John M. (1993). "Technology and Aesthetic Education:
A Crucial Synthesis." Art Education, November (pp. 42-47).
Hirsch, E.D. (1987). Cultural Literacy: What Every
American Needs to Know. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Madya, Stanley, S. (1993). "The Age of the Electronic Image."
The Effect on Art Education. Art Education, November, (pp.
9-14).
Naisbett, John (1990). Megatrends 2000. New
York, Morrow.
Ornstein, Robert E. (1973). Right and Left Thinking.
Psychology Today, (p. 81).
Postman, Neil (1992). Technology: The Surrender
of Culture to Technology. New York: Knopf.
Robinson, Ken (1992). "The Neglect of the Arts in Schools."
The Arts Work Conference, Toronto.
Sagan, C. (1979). The Dragons of Education, Hodder and
Sloughton, London, (p. 207).
Slawson, Brian (1993). "The Gestalt of a Gigabyte."
Art Education, November (pp. 15-22).
Sperry, Roger W. (1975). Left Brain - Right Brain Saturday
Review. August 9th, (p. 33).
Toffler, A. (1990). Powershift. New York:
Bantan Books.
Wilson, Michael (1986). "Learning the Arts: Artistic
Cognition and Artistic Literacy." CSEA, (pp. 15-17). |